Totally agree.
That is why I always brim it and keep a very detailed spreadsheet.
Since owning the A6 and as of 13/06/09 I have (at a fill up on the 23/06/09, not updated the last fill up yet)....
Travelled 6840 miles (all figures below calculated as an average over this milage and 14 tank fills.)
The true average brim to brim MPG is 43.34
The MFD calculated total average MPG is 43.1
This gives an error of 0.27mpg whereby the MFD is under reading !! To me that is pretty damned accurate. Do you know that you can calibrate MFD in vagcom if your is not accurate?
The average tank range achieved measured over 14 tankfulls is 677 miles.
The tank does however hold 70 litres but that is offset by the weight of the vehicle. It is a PD 130 engine by the way.
Still reckon A4's and A3's could do much much better.